The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
A Public Question Does Not Erase a Private Reputation
An editorial urging precise language and careful verification after the Supreme Court’s Gertz decision.
Editorial
The Supreme Court’s decision last week in Gertz v. Robert Welch, Inc. deserves close reading in every newspaper office. The Court held that Elmer Gertz, a lawyer drawn into an account of a public controversy, was neither a public official nor a public figure for the case before it. It reversed the judgment and ordered further proceedings.
The immediate legal questions concern the standards governing a private person’s claim of defamation. The practical question at an editor’s desk is more familiar: what evidence permits the words being placed beside a person’s name? An important public subject gives a newspaper a reason to investigate. It does not supply the proof of every accusation made within that subject.
A lawyer’s representation of a client should be described as representation. Membership, advocacy, responsibility and guilt are different propositions. Each requires its own support. A sentence that runs them together can give a reader a confident conclusion that no reporter has established.
The same care belongs in the small words that hurried editing can remove. An allegation needs an identified source. A denial deserves an accurate statement. A charge and a judgment occupy different places in the course of a case. Saving a few lines by stripping away those distinctions is expensive economy.
The Court has allowed states room to set standards for private-person defamation while forbidding liability without fault. Editors should have counsel explain the decision’s limits. The daily standard of work should also remain intelligible without a lawbook: check the account, read the supporting material, seek the response, and make the published language fit what can be shown.
People with little access to a newspaper’s columns can suffer from a careless account as readily as the powerful. Their appearance in a controversy should increase our care about identifying them and describing their conduct. A correction is necessary when a material error is found; the possibility of printing one later is a reason to establish a dependable procedure now.
A vigorous press needs freedom to examine public affairs. It earns confidence by attending closely to the individuals who appear in that examination. The reader should find the evidence in the story and understand the limit of the conclusion.
Sources & further reading
- Gertz v. Robert Welch, Inc., 418 U.S. 323: opinion and judgment — Justice Lewis F. Powell Jr.; Supreme Court of the United States; primary opinion reproduced by Cornell LII; June 25, 1974.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation