The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
Army Alibi Evidence Undercuts a Claimed Confession in Short Killing
Los Angeles police question the value of a soldier’s statements after evidence places him at his New Jersey post.
LOS ANGELES — The investigation of Elizabeth Short’s killing has turned away from a soldier whose statements had been announced as a confession. Captain Jack Donahoe indicated Tuesday that information placing Corporal Joseph Dumais at Fort Dix, N. J., on January 15 removed him from the suspect list, United Press reported.
The captain said the information put Dumais at his Army post at 5 p.m. that day, only hours after Short’s body was found in Los Angeles. On the evidence then received, he said he would not be justified in sending officers east to bring Dumais back. A full Army report was still awaited.
An AP dispatch from Fort Dix the previous day had described a widening conflict. Nine soldiers had volunteered to give evidence that they saw Dumais at the post during the relevant interval. Army spokesmen were also continuing to describe statements in which he placed himself in California.
Army questioning was continuing. Los Angeles police were awaiting the complete report while their investigation of Short’s killing remained open.
Sources & further reading
- United Press; no individual byline displayed. [Dumais alibi report, Los Angeles dispatch]. Medford Mail Tribune, page 1, 1947-02-11.
- Associated Press; no individual byline displayed. Black Dahlia Case Grows Complicated. The Lethbridge Herald, page 3, 1947-02-10.
Related Herald reporting
- Fingerprints Identify Slain Los Angeles Woman as Elizabeth Short — Frank Delaney, 1947-01-18.
- FBI Opens a Documentary Window on the Unsolved Short Murder — Jeffrey Brooks, 2006-10-21.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation