The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
Maui Revises Lahaina Toll to 97 as Identification Work Continues
Forensic analysis has reduced the earlier count of 115; officials stress that the new number is a minimum.
WAILUKU, Sept. 16.—Maui authorities have revised the Lahaina fire death toll from 115 to at least 97 after more detailed examination showed that some collected remains represented the same people. The adjustment is the result of identification work, not the discovery that the August 8 disaster was less destructive than first understood.
Police Chief John Pelletier said Friday that 74 of the dead had been positively identified. The list of people still unaccounted for fell from 41 to 31. Neither a name on that list nor an unresolved sample establishes an additional death; both are matters for continued investigation.
John Byrd, laboratory director of the Defense POW/MIA Accounting Agency, explained that the number should be understood as a minimum and could rise again. Fire damage and the way people sheltered together have made the work unusually difficult. Separate bags can contain remains from one person, while material from different people can be commingled. Laboratory analysis can therefore revise the first inventory in either direction.
The change is a reminder that disaster numbers measure different stages of knowledge. An early estimate reflects the material recovered and what can be distinguished at the scene. A later count incorporates testing, matching and comparison with other records. Accuracy requires correcting the public total when that work changes the evidence.
The fire destroyed much of Lahaina and forced residents into hurried attempts to escape through streets, toward the shore and into the ocean. The loss remains the nation’s deadliest wildfire in more than a century. Families waiting for an identification are facing a different burden from residents waiting for permission to inspect a home, although both form part of the same recovery.
Officials have not described the search and identification process as complete. The confirmed count, the number identified and the list of people unaccounted for must remain separate figures. Keeping those distinctions visible is a small but necessary part of giving families a reliable record in a disaster that has already taken away so much certainty.
Sources & further reading
- Hawaii officials say DNA tests drop Maui fire death count to 97 — Jennifer Sinco Kelleher and Rebecca Boone / Associated Press; September 15, 2023; syndicated page updated September 18.
- Maui police revise Lahaina wildfire death toll to 97; list of unaccounted for drops to 31 — Wendy Osher / Maui Now; September 15, 2023, 5:28 p.m. HST.
- Maui County revises wildfire death toll down to 97 amid painstaking work to catalog remains — HNN Staff / Hawaii News Now; September 15, 2023; page updated September 16 at 2:46 p.m.HST.
Related Herald reporting
- Lahaina Search Continues as Maui Confirms 53 Fire Deaths — Jennifer Dalton, 2023-08-10.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation