The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
Old Sky Images Remove a 2029 Impact Path for Newly Found Asteroid
Measurements recovered from March photographs have resolved the immediate concern over asteroid 2004 MN4 while leaving a close approach worth studying.

JPL's December 27, 2004 diagram of the asteroid's possible positions during its 2029 passage. The revised uncertainty line misses Earth. NASA/JPL — Near-Earth Object Program Office. Image source · Reuse terms.
PASADENA, Dec. 28.—Astronomers have ruled out an Earth impact in 2029 by asteroid 2004 MN4 after finding it in photographs taken before its discovery. The earlier images extended the observed portion of its orbit and removed the collision paths that had attracted attention during the past week.
Jeff Larsen and Anne Descour of the Spacewatch Observatory near Tucson identified faint images of the asteroid on records dating to March 15. Adding those measurements lengthened the observation interval by three months. The improvement matters because an orbit calculated from a short series of sightings leaves a range of possible future positions.
The asteroid was discovered June 19 by Roy Tucker, David Tholen and Fabrizio Bernardi at Kitt Peak and rediscovered in December. Initial calculations placed its April 13, 2029 passage close enough to Earth that an impact could not be excluded. As observations accumulated, probabilities changed. A preliminary number was an expression of uncertainty in the orbit, not evidence that the asteroid had physically turned toward us.
JPL’s December 23 notice described the object as about 400 meters across and urged further monitoring while cautioning against public alarm. The old photographs have now provided precisely the sort of additional evidence needed: every trajectory remaining compatible with the revised measurements misses Earth and the Moon in 2029.
That close passage will still alter the asteroid’s later path through Earth’s gravitational pull. The current analysis reports no subsequent encounter of concern this century, but later positions are less tightly constrained after such an encounter. Continued observations can improve that calculation without implying that a collision has been predicted.
2004 MN4 is an asteroid orbiting the Sun. It is not a visitor shown to have come from another star. The distinction matters when discussing hazards: an unusual discovery, a close approach and a computed impact possibility are three different things. In this case the immediate warning has led to additional measurements, and those measurements have removed the 2029 collision scenario.
Sources & further reading
- Possibility of an Earth Impact in 2029 Ruled Out for Asteroid 2004 MN4 — Don Yeomans, Steve Chesley and Paul Chodas / NASA/JPL CNEOS; December 27, 2004.
- Near-Earth Asteroid 2004 MN4 Reaches Highest Score To Date On Hazard Scale — Don Yeomans, Steve Chesley and Paul Chodas / NASA/JPL CNEOS; December 23, 2004; subsequent updates.
Related Herald reporting
- Recovered Desert Stones Connect an Asteroid’s Predicted Impact with Its Remains — Adrian Mercer, 2009-03-28.
- Chelyabinsk Study Connects a Brilliant Fireball with a Damaging Shock Wave — Kevin Wallace, 2013-11-08.
- Radar Removes Apophis from the Century’s Impact Risk List — Sarah Nguyen, 2021-03-28.
- Bennu Tracking Narrows the Long Forecast Beyond 2135 — Sarah Nguyen, 2021-08-15.
- Additional Observations Reduce 2032 Asteroid Risk to a Trace — Sarah Nguyen, 2025-02-26.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation