The Aeon Herald / HISTORICAL EDITION
Wrong Envelope Gives Moonlight’s Oscar Moment to La La Land First
The 89th awards end with a correction onstage after the wrong envelope produces an erroneous best-picture announcement.

LOS ANGELES, Feb. 27 — Moonlight won best picture at the 89th Academy Awards last night, but the audience first heard La La Land announced as the winner in an extraordinary breakdown of the ceremony’s final presentation.
Warren Beatty and Faye Dunaway had been given an envelope containing the actress result rather than the picture result. Emma Stone’s name and La La Land appeared on the card. The mistaken announcement brought that film’s producers onto the stage before the error was corrected.
PricewaterhouseCoopers, the firm responsible for handling the results, apologized. Its account places the failure in the delivery of the envelope, not in the Academy’s vote for best picture.
That distinction matters to both sets of filmmakers. Moonlight’s award is the result of the ballot; La La Land’s brief possession of the moment was a mistake in announcing it.
The correction restored the proper winner while leaving an unavoidable question for the Academy and its accountants: how the ceremony’s most closely guarded handoff failed in full view of its audience.
Sources & further reading
Related Herald reporting
- Moonlight Wins Picture After the 89th Oscars’ Corrected Announcement — Camille Jackson, 2017-02-27.
- Academy Removes Envelope Accountants From Future Oscar Shows — Camille Jackson, 2017-03-02.
- Spotlight Wins Picture; The Revenant and Mad Max Share Major Honors — Camille Jackson, 2016-02-29.
- The Shape of Water Wins Four at the 90th Academy Awards — Camille Jackson, 2018-03-05.




Join the conversation