The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
Publish the Terms of the Rescue
An editorial calling for public accounting of the newly enacted financial rescue authority.
Editorial
The financial rescue law signed October 3 permits troubled-asset purchases to rise, through specified steps, to $700 billion outstanding at one time. It also creates oversight, audit and reporting requirements. The size of the authority makes those provisions central to the public bargain.
Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson has argued that the legislation will help restore the flow of credit to businesses and consumers. That is a claim the public must be able to examine as the program develops. A taxpayer should be able to follow the connection between a particular intervention and the economic purpose offered for it.
Begin with the terms. When public money is committed, publish the recipient, the asset or obligation acquired, the method used to determine its price and the protections obtained in return. Where commercial or operational circumstances justify a temporary delay, identify the information withheld and explain when its release will be reconsidered. Confidentiality should have a reason and a review date.
The accounting must keep different quantities separate. Purchase authority, commitments, money paid, assets held and eventual gains or losses describe different stages. Adding them together, or substituting the largest available number for the cost already incurred, would obscure both the risk and the result. Readers deserve a ledger whose terms remain consistent from one announcement to the next.
Oversight bodies should have access to the records required to test Treasury’s account. Their findings ought to be presented in language a depositor, employee or small-business owner can use. The question extends beyond whether a transaction was lawfully executed. It includes whether its price was justified and whether the public received the protection promised.
Government must also explain how it will judge the program’s effect on credit. A stronger institution may still leave a sound local business struggling to borrow. Officials should state their measures of improvement before favorable figures tempt them to select a convenient standard afterward.
The urgency of the crisis warrants prompt work. It also warrants a record that can survive the crisis. Every commitment made under this extraordinary authority should leave a trail from the public purpose to the decision, the expenditure and the result.
Sources & further reading
- Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008, Division A, Public Law 110-343, especially sections 104–105, 115–116, 121 and 125 — United States Congress; enrolled public law; October 3, 2008.
- Statement by Secretary Henry M. Paulson, Jr. on Emergency Economic Stabilization Act — Henry M. Paulson Jr.; U.S. Department of the Treasury; September 28, 2008.
Related Herald reporting
- Lehman Bankruptcy Move Tests the Separation of Firm and Customer Assets — Jason Parker, 2008-09-16.
- Recession Began in December 2007, Dating Committee Finds — Michael Carver, 2008-12-02.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation