The Aeon Herald / HERALD ORIGINAL
The Public Record Must Outlast a Presidency
An editorial calling for preservation of evidence and sustained public scrutiny after President Nixon’s resignation.
Editorial
Richard Nixon resigned the presidency yesterday. The departure of a President changes the administration of the government. It also makes the preservation of the record an immediate public obligation. The documents and recordings needed to establish what occurred must remain available to lawful inquiry.
Last month, in United States v. Nixon, the Supreme Court rejected a generalized claim of presidential confidentiality as sufficient to defeat the demand for evidence in the criminal proceeding before it. The Court recognized the importance of confidential presidential communications while requiring the particular material to be examined through judicial procedures. That distinction should guide a careful account of the ruling.
The country now needs the same care in its expectations. Resignation is an established fact. The legal responsibility of particular individuals remains a matter for the proceedings and evidence applicable to them. A newspaper should report each development accurately, giving an allegation, a judicial finding and a political judgment their proper names.
There is a strong human desire to close a painful chapter. Public confidence, however, requires a dependable account of the chapter being closed. Records should be secured against destruction or casual removal, their custody made clear, and disputes about access resolved through lawful means. Necessary safeguards for private or security-sensitive material should be stated with particularity.
Congress should continue the work of examining how public authority was exercised and where existing restraints failed. The change in office should neither suspend that inquiry nor determine its conclusions in advance. Recommendations for reform will be stronger when readers can see the evidence to which they respond.
The press has continuing work as well. Follow the cases after the largest headline has passed. Correct the errors disclosed by a fuller record. Explain the legal process without promising a result that has yet to occur. Give the public a way to distinguish an account supported by documents from an assertion offered in someone’s defense.
A constitutional succession can be carried out promptly. Rebuilding confidence demands patience and proof. Preserving the record is one practical act that serves both the present government and the citizens who must judge its conduct.
Sources & further reading
- Letter resigning the Office of President of the United States — Richard M. Nixon; original letter to Secretary of State Henry A. Kissinger, held by the National Archives; August 9, 1974.
- United States v. Nixon, 418 U.S. 683: opinion of the Court — Chief Justice Warren E. Burger; Supreme Court of the United States; primary opinion reproduced by Justia; July 24, 1974.
HERALD ORIGINAL


Join the conversation