The Aeon Herald / HISTORICAL EDITION
Section 14 Places Palm Springs’ Growth Beside the Cost of Displacement
The clearance of housing on Agua Caliente land raises distinct questions about tenants’ homes, tribal property and outside control.

Palm Canyon Drive in a 1950s postcard, postmarked February 28, 1959. The resort’s commercial image provides context; Section 14’s removals are not pictured. Credit: Postcards of the Desert, via Wikimedia Commons. Original source. Public domain in the United States: published before 1978 without copyright notice, as documented in the Commons record.
PALM SPRINGS, Dec. 18.—The resort city’s growth has brought the future of Section 14 into sharp relief. On this square mile of Agua Caliente land near downtown, housing clearance and redevelopment have reached people whose work helps sustain Palm Springs but whose access to its housing has been sharply limited.
Many of the tenants have been Black or Mexican American workers and their families. Their position differs from that of Agua Caliente landowners, whose property is held under federal trust arrangements. A fair account must follow both interests without treating the tenants and the landholders as the same group.
Short leases, poor infrastructure and exclusion from housing elsewhere have helped produce the conditions now invoked to justify clearance. Calling a settlement substandard does not answer where its residents can go. Nor does a development proposal, by itself, establish that a Native landowner has exercised meaningful control over the terms.
The band’s leaders have sought longer leases and a stronger economic position while resisting proposals that would end their federal relationship. Individual landholders have also had to deal with outside supervision and advice. Those arrangements deserve scrutiny whenever decisions made in an owner’s name may principally benefit someone else.
The loss of a home is immediate, while the benefits promised by redevelopment are often deferred. A responsible public account needs the actual sequence of notices, removals and clearance, together with the authority invoked at each step. The presence of several agencies makes that accounting more necessary.
Palm Springs’ prosperity should be examined from the places where its workers live and from the position of the people who own its tribal land. The city’s familiar picture of leisure leaves much of that relationship outside the frame.
Explore the Story
Sources & further reading.
Related Herald reporting
- A Younger Generation Organizes to Speak for Itself — Thomas Navarro, 1961-09-03.
- Fishing Families Put Treaty Promises on the Riverbank — Thomas Navarro, 1964-03-08.
- Voting Rights Act Gives Federal Force to the Fight Against Racial Exclusion — Thomas Navarro, 1965-08-07.
- California Indian Legal Services Builds a Practice Around Tribal Rights — Thomas Navarro, 1967-12-17.
- Indian Civil Rights Act Sets Individual Protections Within Tribal Government — Thomas Navarro, 1968-04-12.
- Blue Lake Return Gives Land to a Policy of Self-Determination — Thomas Navarro, 1970-12-16.
- Agua Caliente’s Women Leaders Press for Control of Their Land’s Future — William Keane, 1959-12-13.
- Rincon Appeal Ends on a Jurisdiction Question, Leaving County Authority Unsettled — Katherine “Kate” Romero, 1974-06-16.
- New Law Offers Tribes a Greater Role in Running Federal Programs — Katherine “Kate” Romero, 1975-01-05.
- California Rancheria Law Sets Conditions for Ending Federal Trust Relations — Joan Mercer, 1958-08-19.
- New Law Extends California’s Court Jurisdiction Into Indian Country — William Keane, 1953-08-16.
- Congress Announces a Policy of Ending Federal Supervision of Indian Tribes — Edward Hensley, 1953-08-02.
- New Indian Law Halts Allotment and Opens a Different Course for Tribal Government — Samuel Voss, 1934-06-19.






Join the conversation